Paperjam.lu

 Flickr user Håkan Dahlström/Creative Commons (2011)

European merchants can longer be charged certain card payment fees that generate several billion euros in revenue, the EU’s top court has ruled, ending nearly seven years of litigation.

The case began in December 2007 when the European Commission’s competition bureau ordered MasterCard, the card payment system, to stop charging “multilateral interchange fees” within six months. Merchants pay MIF, which represents up to 0.3% of each transaction, through the bank that handles their card transactions.

That adds up to €9 billion annually across Europe, according to Ruth Milligan of Eurocommerce, a group that represents retailers and was a party to the proceedings against MasterCard. This figure includes other payment systems, such as Visa.

In its 2007 decision, “the commission found that the MIF had the effect of setting a floor under the costs charged to merchants and thus constituted a restriction of price competition,” according to the European Court of Justice in Kirchberg.

MasterCard fought the commission’s ruling in the EU General Court, which is also part of the plateau’s European judicial complex. The General Court upheld the commission’s decision in May 2012, leading MasterCard to appeal to the ECJ on several points of law.

Among other objections, the financial firm argued that the fees were “objectively necessary for the MasterCard system” and that “the General Court did not sufficiently analyse the competitive effects of the MIF”.

Payment system can function without MIF, says court

On Thursday, the ECJ judges rejected those claims and upheld the lower court’s verdict. It ruled that the merchant charges were not necessary because the MasterCard “system was still capable of functioning without those fees”, and that “the General Court carried out a detailed examination in its judgment in order to determine in particular whether the MIF limit the pressure which merchants can exert on acquiring banks when negotiating the costs charged by those banks. The General Court thus correctly concluded that the MIF had restrictive effects on competition.”

“MasterCard has lost on all its arguments,” Milligan told Delano on Thursday. “That is strong success for the argument that interchanges fees are anticompetitive” and “in breach of EU treaties”.

The president of MasterCard Europe called the ruling “disappointing”. Javier Perez said in a statement: “When MasterCard brought this action in 2007 we did so because we believed then, as we do now, that market-based solutions are the best way to ensure a fair and competitive payments landscape in Europe--one that makes consumers’ lives easier, and brings increased business for merchants. Today’s negative judgment will have little or no impact on how MasterCard operates”.

The case was C-382/12 P (MasterCard Inc. and Others v Commission). The payment firm has no further legal recourse.

Earlier this year, the commission proposed further MIF limitations.