Imagine opening a parcel without knowing its contents, like a Christmas present. A total surprise, an adrenalin rush. That’s the experience offered by “mystery boxes,” a phenomenon that is gaining in popularity in neighbouring countries. In reality, these mystery boxes are undelivered parcels that have never been claimed and that carriers sell to retailers. The latter in turn resell them to consumers without opening the packaging.
From the latest iPhone to a cashmere jumper, a simple pair of socks or a few odds and ends, anything can be found in these parcels. The concept, which is legal, is based on the fact that after 30 days without a claim, the parcels are declared lost, as the newspaper L’Alsace explains. The French anti-waste law, in force since 1 January 2022, which prohibits the destruction of unsold products, has also encouraged the development of this concept in France, where manufacturers and distributors must now donate or recycle their products, according to the government.
However, a legal loophole remains, as the 60 Millions de consommateurs association points out. “According to the legal experts at the Institut national de la consommation, specific legislation is needed, because consumers find themselves unable to assert their rights. With a parcel containing unidentified products, no pre-contractual information on the goods is provided.”
Limited practices in Luxembourg
In response to a parliamentary question from MP Joëlle Welfring (déi Gréng), the minister for consumer protection,
Martine Hansen (CSV), pointed out that such practices are still rare in Luxembourg. When consulted, the Institut luxembourgeois de régulation (ILR) and the Union luxembourgeoise des consommateurs (ULC) confirmed that no permanent entity of this type exists in the country. However, ephemeral online sales organised by King Colis, a French company, have already taken place in the country.
The ILR points out that, under Luxembourg postal law, a parcel always belongs to the sender until it has been delivered to the recipient. If a postal service provider is unable to deliver a parcel or identify its sender, it must pass the item on to ILR, which has sole authority to decide its fate. It is therefore illegal to sell undeliverable parcels from a postal service in Luxembourg.
However, the institute cannot intervene for parcels originating from other countries. It is therefore not possible for it to intervene if parcels from other countries are offered for sale in Luxembourg, as was the case with King Colis.
Consumer protection: increased vigilance
Hansen also highlighted the findings of a study by the German consumer organisation, Stiftung Warentest, published on 13 January. The study raises a number of questions about consumer protection, particularly with regard to age restrictions, the protection of minors, the conditions for returning goods and the lack of a right of withdrawal.
Although the ULC has not yet received any complaints relating to these practices, it remains vigilant and plans to raise public awareness via an information campaign on social networks, in order to prevent any abuses.
This article was originally published in French.
