Amazon, Microsoft and Google, who already take three quarters of the European cloud market, are going to find themselves an advantage in the new Framework published by the European Commission… in the name of European sovereignty. (Photo: Shutterstock)

Amazon, Microsoft and Google, who already take three quarters of the European cloud market, are going to find themselves an advantage in the new Framework published by the European Commission… in the name of European sovereignty. (Photo: Shutterstock)

Presented at the end of October, the new European Cloud Framework will enable Google, Amazon and Microsoft to be considered as European sovereign cloud operators thanks to the weighting introduced by the European Commission. It was either that or, without the Americans, Europe no longer had enough cloud providers to meet its needs. Funny, painful or inevitable, depending on where you look…

Let's put it simply: if the European Commission had really wanted to build a sovereign cloud, it had just one sentence to write - “Zero extra-European legal dependency”. One line and the hyperscalers would automatically be out of the running. Except that such a choice would have brought Europe face to face with a far more uncomfortable truth: without the Americans, the EU simply does not have the infrastructure, the software or the players capable of absorbing its own digital needs. Ten years behind schedule, hesitant industrial decisions, a virtual absence of software champions… The result: a dependence so profound that sovereignty now needs to be redefined so that it remains compatible with those from whom we claim to be emancipated.

The Cloud Sovereignty Framework, established by the European Commission, evaluates cloud providers according to eight criteria covering the entire value chain: strategic sovereignty (governance, shareholding, decision-making location), legal and jurisdictional sovereignty (applicable laws, exposure to non-European legislation), data and AI sovereignty (location, access, encryption, use of data), operational sovereignty (operation, maintenance, support), supply chain (origin and control of hardware and software), technological sovereignty (interoperability, open standards, reversibility), security and compliance (SOC, audits, incident response), as well as environmental sustainability.

Sovereignty, a weighted average

Each criterion is then assessed according to five maturity levels, known as SEALs (Sovereignty Effectiveness Assurance Levels). These levels range from a minimum threshold, reflecting very limited sovereignty, to a maximum threshold, corresponding to complete control of the criterion in question. This graduated system enables a supplier to obtain very contrasting profiles: excellent in security, average in technology, weak in legal terms, while remaining fully eligible for the overall assessment. Sovereignty, Brussels version, is no longer an absolute status: it is a weighted average.

These results are finally aggregated into a single score calculated from an official weighting of the eight criteria. Supply chain (SOV-5) is the most heavily weighted criterion at 20%, ahead of strategic sovereignty (15%), operational sovereignty (15%) and technological sovereignty (15%). Legal sovereignty (10%), data and AI sovereignty (10%) and security & compliance (10%) weigh significantly less, while environmental sustainability accounts for just 5% of the total. This is where the European Commission has already made its choice: the Framework makes it mathematically possible for legally non-sovereign suppliers to be eligible.

390,000 configurations for few elected representatives

Legal and jurisdictional sovereignty (SOV-2), which conditions exposure to US law, only accounts for 10% of the total score. Conversely, the criteria in which the American giants excel - supply chain (20%), operations (15%), technology (15%) and security (10%) - alone account for more than 60% of the final score. From a strictly accounting point of view, a supplier subject to the Cloud Act can therefore compensate for its legal dependence by its industrial power, its level of tooling or its local operational capabilities. This is exactly how companies that are legally dependent on a third country can claim “sovereign cloud” status.

This weighting logic is compounded by a second structural grey area: the Framework does not make public, in a detailed and enforceable manner, the precise criteria for moving from one SEAL level to another. The levels formally exist, from 0 to 4 for each of the eight pillars, but their allocation is based on grids of questions specific to each European Commission call for tenders, and not on a transparent universal benchmark.

Mathematically, this breakdown produces more than 390,000 theoretical configurations of “sovereignty”. In other words, the framework does not define a single model of sovereign cloud, but a constellation of profiles, some of which may be brightly green while remaining legally dependent. And it is on the basis of this framework that the first four winners of an initial European public procurement contract of fairly limited scope will be chosen, and Post Luxembourg is already hoping to be one of these four.

Forget sovereignty, let's talk collaboration

Beyond the political and legal debate, the Cloud Sovereignty Framework also opens up a new round of administrative complexity for all suppliers. To obtain a score, each will have to document, prove, audit and constantly update its practices in eight separate areas: governance, applicable law, data architecture, security, operations, supply chain, technology and environmental impact.

This means voluminous technical files, recurring audits, contractual justifications and different compliance processes for each call for tenders. In practice, sovereignty also becomes a bureaucratic exercise.

This extra paperwork mechanically favours the players with the best legal resources, compliance teams and audit capacity, to the detriment of smaller or specialist suppliers. Where a hyperscaler already has armies dedicated to certification and compliance, many European players will have to mobilise disproportionate resources to keep up with a changing framework. For the European Commission, the Framework provides a structure for evaluation; for suppliers, it adds an additional layer of regulation, which is cumbersome and costly, and which will have to evolve as the markets evolve.

Unless we imagine a regulatory omnibus even before the measures actually come into force… but sovereignty has been better defended in the past. So, like East German rowers at the Olympic Games, from the Prime Minister, Luc FriedenLuc Frieden, to Head of cloud of Deep (by Post Group),, Philipp JäggiPhilipp Jäggi, everyone is moving forward to the sound of necessary collaboration. That's all very well, but what about sovereignty?