Finance Minister Gilles Roth (CSV) believes that "this budget is designed to meet the major missions of the contemporary State, in particular by strengthening social cohesion without making cuts in social spending." He emphasised the continuity of tax cuts and the importance of investment, including in military spending to meet NATO commitments. Lastly, he believes that his draft paves the way for the tax reform planned for 2028, focused on individualising personal taxation.
Social investment accounts for 46.9% of the budget.
The contradiction will not be brought to him by Marc Spautz, the leader of the CSV fraction who congratulated the minister on his speech. While waiting to examine the figures in detail, he stressed that the main message was the emphasis on the notion of the "whole". "This budget highlights the government's budgetary priorities, in particular the significant social investment which accounts for 46.9% of the budget. As far as the housing crisis is concerned, we are moving in the right direction."
State finances are in good shape.
Satisfied Gilles Baum, President of the DP fraction, who described the Minister's speech as committed and comprehensive, and emphasised the State's sound financial health and controlled management of public debt "which remains well below the threshold of 30% of GDP". "The State's finances are in good shape. He highlights the ongoing investment planned in crucial areas such as housing - "two billion over the next four years" - the fight against poverty, economic diversification (particularly in finance and new technologies), and mobility infrastructure. He also stresses the importance of intelligent investment in defence and cyber security, and notes that continued investment is helping to create and safeguard jobs despite an unemployment rate forecast at around 6% for 2026. "Of course, we would like to have a lower unemployment rate, but it is difficult given the economic situation in Luxembourg and the eurozone."
We need to invest in people.
For the leader of the LSAP faction, Taina Bofferding, the budget lacks vision and clarity regarding social objectives. She criticised the frequent use of the word "together", "heard at least 1,000 times" from Gilles Roth, "when this government is not in favour of social dialogue". "This budget contains a lot of figures, but no concrete projects to support these investments, such as the problem of housing. She also deplored the lack of detail on measures to counter the rise in poverty and the absence of precise figures for new social programmes. "I hope that the budget will not be limited to promises and that actions will actually be implemented." And to conclude "we need to invest in people".
The CSV practices a left-wing fiscal policy.
Fred Keup, president of the ADR fraction, came away from the presentation very sceptical. He was even dissatisfied. He believes that the project presented today "lacks seriousness and is not sustainable". In his sights was the 1.49 billion deficit announced. "This is irresponsible on the part of a party like the CSV, which until now has had a reputation for budgetary stability. The CSV is now practising a left-wing budgetary policy based on systematic recourse to borrowing. This is detrimental to Luxembourg's stability."
The Finance Minister juggles with the figures.
Sam Tanson (déi Gréng) left the presentation astonished "at the way the Finance Minister juggles figures, comparing apples with pears". In her sights was the example of the evolution of the debt, for which the Minister of Finance referred to the 2023 note to the trainer when, in her opinion, he should have referred to the last multiannual plan. "And here we see that the trend is upwards and not downwards". She also deplored the fact that the impact of the tax reform, once again scheduled for 1 January 2028, did not appear in the draft 2025-2029 financial plan. "With the 900 million that this reform would cost, we could soon find ourselves with a debt level close to 30%". The Green MP does not deny that she is against debt "if it is used to invest". And she "doesn't see any new investment in infrastructure".
While she welcomes the aid for households in the face of electricity prices and the announcement of GDP well-being, she regrets that the climate issue is only addressed on the fringes and that the definition of GDP well-being is too limited in terms of protecting nature.
An accountant's speech.
For Sven Clement (Piraten), Gilles Roth's presentation amounted to "a non-visionary accountant's speech. A speech given in the absence of CEO Luc Frieden". He has serious doubts about the 5% growth in revenues, which he deems "unrealistic" given the economic context. He also criticised the "watering can" approach to tackling the poverty crisis. As far as the "housing catastrophe" is concerned - we have reached a stage where the term crisis no longer has any meaning - he considers the government's effort to be insufficient. "It barely covers a quarter of annual needs."
Finally, he expresses concern about the 82% increase in the debt burden since the government took office, attributing this to unhealthy cash management in addition to rising interest rates.
Housing and climate not getting enough investment.
For David Wagner (déi Lénk), the draft budget is marked by a major imbalance in favour of defence spending and "militarisation" at the expense of "more urgent areas such as housing and climate, which are not receiving sufficient investment". For him, military investment is not inevitable, "just look at what is happening in Spain", he says.
David Wagner also highlights the reappearance of the scissor effect - i.e. expenditure rising faster than revenue - due to "a regressive tax policy favouring companies". He also criticises tax breaks in the housing sector - "giveaways" -, arguing for more public investment.
Finally, he notes that, on the projections to 2029, unemployment benefits are supposed not to increase. In his view, this is "fanciful".







