The “social advantages” of stepparents ought to be extended to those financially dependent on them, according to an initial opinion by an advocate general at the European Court of Justice, in Kirchberg.
The question stemmed from three separate cases, filed by Noémie Depesme, Adrien Kaufmann and Maxine Lefort. Their applications to the Grand Duchy’s government for university financial aid--available to children of cross-border commuters--were denied in 2013.
Depeseme and Kaufmann live in Lorraine, France; Lefort lives in the Belgian province of Luxembourg. All three have stepfathers who work in the Grand Duchy; their biological fathers are either divorced from their mothers or deceased. The students said in court filings that they were financially dependent, to varying degrees, on their stepfathers.
However, Luxembourg’s higher education ministry said they “could not be classified as ‘children’ of frontier workers as only their stepfathers worked in Luxembourg”, according to the preliminary opinion.
Last July the Cour administrative (Higher Administrative Court) asked the ECJ if “the parent-child relationship may be regarded not just from a legal point of view but also from an economic point of view” under European law.
On Thursday, Melchior Wathelet--an advocate general at the court since 2012 and a former ECJ justice--said that the economic link was key.
“The condition of contributing to the maintenance of the child derives from a factual situation, and it is not necessary to determine the reason why such support is given or to make a precise estimation of its extent,” he wrote.
The matter will now be considered by a panel of ECJ judges. They are not obliged to follow the recommendations by advocate generals, but in 80% of cases they reach the same conclusion.
The joined cases are C-401/15, C-402/15 and C-403/15 (Depesme and Kerrou, Kaufmann, Lefort v Ministre de l’Enseignement supérieur et de la Recherche).

