Paperjam.lu

An internet user takes advantage of free wifi outside of a closed café in Heidelberg, southwestern Germany, at 11:30pm on 20 July 2006. Photo: Raul Lieberwirth (Creative Commons) 

The decision stems from a case filed in Bavaria by Sony Music against Tobias Mc Fadden, who runs a lighting and sound system shop that offers free wifi to attract customers, according to court documents. 

In 2010, one of those customers illegally downloaded a track. A regional court in Munich asked the European Court of Justice if Mc Fadden could be held indirectly liable under the European electronic commerce directive.

On Thursday, the ECJ judges said a communication service provider such as Mc Fadden could not. “The copyright holder is not entitled to claim compensation on the ground that the network was used by third parties to infringe its rights,” the court stated in an announcement. In addition, Sony could not reclaim its legal fees in the case. 

At the same time, the Munich court’s “injunction ordering the internet connection to be secured by means of a password” strikes a valid balance between intellectual property rights and network freedom. A password would “require users to reveal their identity” and avoid anonymous downloads. 

Following the ruling, Mc Fadden said the decision was “disappointing” as it hindered the development of free wifi in Europe, Deutsche Welle reported. 

As of this writing, Sony had not returned Delano’s message seeking comment. 

The matter now returns to the German court system for final adjudication.

The case was C-484/14 (Tobias Mc Fadden v Sony Music Entertainment Germany GmbH).