Paperjam.lu

A screenshot from the 2015 annual report (PDF) issued by Food Empire, the company that owns Future Enterprises and the MacCoffee brand 

The case was filed by the Singaporean company Future Enterprises. It owns a line of instant coffee called MacCoffee, which launched in the 1990s and is mainly distributed in eastern Europe, Asia and Africa.

In 2008 Future Enterprises applied to trademark “MacCoffee” in the EU with the European Union Intellectual Property Office. Originally the EUIPO granted the trademark, but then reversed itself in 2012 following objections from McDonald’s, which already held several similar trademarks in the EU, such as “McMuffin”, “McNuggets” and “Big Mac”.

The MacCoffee stand during a trade fair in Paris, October 2012, published on MacCoffee’s Facebook page
The MacCoffee stand during a trade fair in Paris, October 2012, published on MacCoffee’s Facebook page

The following year, the Singapore firm asked the EU General Court to reverse that reversal, arguing, among other points, that the public can easily tell the difference between the fast food chain’s brand and its own.

A McCafé in France, in 2009. Photo: McDonald’s Europe Virtual Press Office
A McCafé in France, in 2009. Photo: McDonald’s Europe Virtual Press Office

On Tuesday, the EU General Court, in Kirchberg, upheld the EUIPO decision, saying that there was a risk that the “public could mentally establish a link between the conflicting trade marks” and “that it was highly probable that the applicant took unfair advantage of the reputation of the McDonald’s trade mark”.

Future Enterprises can file an appeal to the European Court of Justice, located in the same Kirchberg judicial complex, within two months of the ruling. A representative of its parent company, Food Empire, told Delano that the firm’s lawyers “are studying the points of the judgement and its implications. The company may make further appeal against the decision.” The group, she added, only “sells a very small amount of MacCoffee products in the EU”, and has bigger sales among its frozen food lines.

The case is number T-518/13 (Future Enterprises v EUIPO).

The EU judicial complex in Kirchberg, in March 2014. Photo: Benjamin Champenois
The EU judicial complex in Kirchberg, in March 2014. Photo: Benjamin Champenois