Paperjam.lu

A demonstrator at Luxembourg’s central courthouse holds a T-shirt that reads, “I support Antoine”, during the “LuxLeaks” trial of Antoine Deltour, Raphaël Halet and Édouard Perrin, on 26 April 2016. Photo: Sven Becker 

In an open letter, 108 MEPs stated (PDF) that they hoped “the intimate ties between the Luxembourg tax administration and corporations like PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC)... will be investigated upon by all possible means”.

That does not necessarily mean a criminal inquiry, one of the signatories, Sven Giegold told Delano.

The parliamentarians’ letter also called for Marius Kohl--the former head of ACD’s corporate tax unit 6, who approved many of the tax rulings disclosed in the “LuxLeaks” cache--to be compelled to “provide adequate responses concerning these practices before the relevant statutory limitation becomes applicable in Luxembourg”.

Letter of support

The open letter, released on Thursday, was addressed to Antoine Deltour and Raphaël Halet, and sent “to express our support and solidarity with you in light of the on-going judicial proceedings against you in Luxembourg”.

Deltour and Halet, former employees of the consultancy PwC in the Grand Duchy, stood trial in May for stealing and leaking thousands of confidential tax documents to Édouard Perrin, a journalist who had been charged as an accomplice.

Prosecutors had asked for prison terms of 18 months, but in June, Deltour was given a suspended sentence of 12 months and Halet was given a suspended sentence of 9 months. Perrin was acquitted. Deltour and Halet have appealed the convictions, and prosecutors said they would also appeal the verdict and seek stiffer sentences. That appeal hearing is expected to take place later this year or early next year.

Kohl, who retired from the tax service in 2013, did not testify at Deltour and Halet’s trial--nor during the European Parliament hearings on the tax rulings--as he had a medical excuse.

Tax rulings compliant

Luxembourg’s tax office declined to comment on the letter. Delano was unable to locate Kohl, and an official with the ACD said it was “not possible” for the agency to forward Delano’s request for comment to him. However, Kohl told the Wall Street Journal in 2014 that he was never pressured by political leaders, and he was praised in the article by a tax advisor as being hardworking and a straight shooter. Over the past two years, Luxembourg’s finance ministry has repeated stressed that the Grand Duchy’s tax system complies with EU and international norms.

As of this writing, PwC had not returned Delano’s request for comment.

In the letter to Deltour and Halet, the MEPs stated that: “We certainly respect the independence of the Luxembourg judiciary but we were shocked and angered by your conviction despite the recognition by the court of your status” as whistleblowers.

Political discord

The vast majority of the MEPs who signed are members of the GUE/NGL (European United Left/Nordic Green Left), centre-left Socialists & Democrats, and Greens/European Free Alliance blocs.

None of Luxembourg’s six MEPs signed the letter. One of them, Frank Engel, of the centre-right European People’s Party bloc that includes the CSV, told Delano that he does not believe Deltour was a whistleblower. The ex-PwC employee “is someone who knew exactly why he worked where he worked” and “simply stole material the use of which he resolved to clarify later”, in the MEP’s view.

Engel said in an email on Friday: “These people have been rightfully convicted for acts relevant to criminal law. I shall not participate in any totally spurious glorification of small-time would-be investigators, and I find the fact that some people do engage in such behaviour lamentable.”

More hearings

Giegold--a German MEP with the GUE/NGL bloc who testified for the defence in the LuxLeaks trial--told Delano that: “I stand ready to give any more evidence if needed” at future hearings. And, of course, I will not stop until we have a European framework to protect whistleblowers” and the press.

“We expect that the commission and Mr Juncker are finally putting forward such a legal framework” that will be released in the near future, Giegold said by phone, referring to Jean-Claude Juncker, the current president of the European Commission and former prime minister of Luxembourg.

Fresh European Parliament tax hearings will begin this autumn, and Giegold noted, “the role of intermediaries [such as tax advisors] is one of the core issues for the inquiry.”