In a letter sent to Luxembourg’s government, the commission accused the Grand Duchy of providing illegal state aid to McDonald’s by issuing a tax ruling, also known as a “comfort letter”, that turned a blind eye to the terms spelled out in an agreement with Washington. The letter (PDF) was sent on 3 December 2015, and a redacted version of the document was posted to the commission’s website on Monday.
A spokesman for Luxembourg’s finance ministry said that “the commission has published the non-confidential version of the decision it had already taken on 3 December 2015 to open an in-depth investigation with regard to the tax treatment of McDonalds. This publication is a mere formal step in the procedure.”
More than €1bn saved?
McDonald’s subsidiaries, mainly one called McD Europe, were set up in Cloche d’Or in 2009, and hold franchise and intellectual property rights to the US-based restaurant chain across the EU and Russia.
According to the report “Unhappy Meal” (PDF), issued in February by the trade union campaign group No Tax Fraud, McDonald’s saved €1.06bn in taxes between 2009 and 2013 by routing revenue through its Luxembourg operations, which employed 13 people.
The commission letter said that, in 2014, Europe generated $11bn of McDonald’s $27bn global income
The allegations of favourable treatment hinged on an apparent loophole in the double taxation treaty between the Grand Duchy and the US.
In an initial ruling dated 30 March 2009, Luxembourg’s tax service said certain McDonald’s revenues could be exempt from taxation in the Grand Duchy if the company could “submit proof on a yearly basis that those profits have been declared and are subject to tax” by American authorities.
The headquarters of Luxembourg’s tax service in the city centre on 3 March 2015. Photo: Christophe Olinger
“No requirement”
But in a subsequent filing, a tax advisor for McD Europe’s stated that, under the treaty, “the income may be taxed in the US” but “there is however no requirement that the other contracting state (US) effectively taxes this income”.
In a 17 September 2009 letter, Luxembourg’s tax service agreed that revenue that “may” be taxed in the US would be exempt from taxation in the Grand Duchy, according to the European Commission.
“In the commission’s views, Luxembourg therefore deliberately granted the ruling with a tax exemption under the Luxembourg-US [double taxation treaty], although having all information necessary to be aware that no taxation would take place in the US”, stated the competition authority’s December letter.
“Luxembourg has submitted all requested information to the commission and is fully cooperating with the commission in the investigation, the finance ministry spokesman told Delano on Friday. “Luxembourg is confident it will be able to convince the commission in due time that no selective advantage has been granted.”
In addition, the commission letter itself noted the Grand Duchy government’s previous position: that its “measures are fully in line with Luxembourg law and do not constitute state aid”, and that “tax administrations need to be allowed a certain degree of flexibility when applying the provisions of their tax law to cases of individual taxpayers.”
Antoine Deltour at the central courthouse in Luxembourg City, where his LuxLeaks trial took place, in May. Photo: Sven Becker
“We pay the taxes that are owed”
A spokesman for the company told Delano on Thursday that: “McDonald’s is committed to continuing our substantial and positive contribution to the European economy. We pay the taxes that are owed, and from 2011-2015 McDonald’s companies paid more than $2.5 billion just in corporate income taxes in the European Union, with an average tax rate approaching 27%. We pay these taxes in the countries where we operate.”
“Our independent franchisees, who own and operate approximately 75% of McDonald’s restaurants across Europe, also pay corporate tax and many other taxes,” the spokesman wrote in an email. “In addition to corporate income taxes, McDonald’s companies and our franchisees pay significant social, property and other taxes where we operate.”
He said: “We are subject to the same tax laws as other companies and anticipate that the inquiry will be resolved favourably.”
The commission has also pursued similar cases--launched following the LuxLeaks revelations--against Apple, Amazon, Fiat, Google and Starbucks. America’s treasury secretary has accused Brussels of unfairly targeting US companies, which the European competition commissioner has denied.
Margrethe Vestager, the European competition commissioner, arrives for the weekly European Commission cabinet meeting in Brussels on 1 June 2016. Photo: European Commission
This article has been updated to include comments from Luxembourg’s finance ministry



