Paperjam.lu

Nicolas Henckes during an interview published in the May 2012 print edition of Delano. Photo: Luc Deflorenne 

In late October, the European Commission gave a new push to establish a European Common Consolidated Corporate Tax Base, an ambitious tool to fight tax avoidance and make tax payments easier for companies.

The proposal is made of two draft directives: a common definition of taxable profits, and a ‘consolidation’ system allowing companies to add up all the profits and losses of their subsidiaries in different EU member states, to reach a net profit or loss for the entire EU.

This is the second time that the European executive is proposing a CCCTB. A first attempt, back in 2011, ended in a deadlock as member states opposed the proposal. But the commission hopes that the recent LuxLeaks and BahamasLeaks scandals have created new momentum for the draft rules.

But to make sure the text won’t be rejected again, the commission made some changes to its 2011 proposal. First, the CCCTB system would be mandatory, and not optional. It would apply to multinational groups with global revenues exceeding €750m a year.

Consolidation was the most controversial issue back in 2011, and one of the reasons why the proposal was never agreed between finance ministers. The commission now proposes a two-step approach, meaning the member states would first agree on the common base (with rules applicable starting in 2019) then on the consolidation aspect (thus applicable in 2021).

In the meantime, companies will be able to offset profits in one EU country against losses in another. Once the consolidation is implemented, that would de facto mean the end of transfer pricing in the EU, which is one of the main vehicles for profit shifting within groups.

Secondly, the proposal now has a stronger focus on fighting tax avoidance, instead of being just a tool to make life simpler for firms. The commission also added its own tax incentives. One aims at fostering research and innovation through a super deduction scheme, where startups would be allowed to deduct twice their R&D expenses.

If adopted as such by finance ministers, the CCCTB would have a notable impact on national budgets. According to the commission’s calculations, Luxembourg would see the biggest impact, with a decrease of corporate tax revenues equivalent to 1% of its GDP, followed by the UK (-0.88%) and Spain (-0.61%).

NGOs welcome the proposal, yet are worried about the timing. “The CCCTB is what we need to tackle tax avoidance, but with the consolidation scheme,” said Tove Maria Ryding of the European Network on Debt and Development. “If we work only on the common base, we actually reinforce existing loopholes--for example through this R&D deduction scheme.”

The private sector is even more sceptical. BusinessEurope said it regrets that consolidation would be mandatory. “CCCTB could be a good thing for multinational companies,” Nicolas Henckes of the Union des Entreprises Luxembourgeoises told Delano. “But let’s be clear: it is a very complicated text, and I am not sure that finance ministers will agree on it.”

This article was first published in the December 2016 issue of Delano magazine. Be the first to read Delano articles on paper before they’re posted online, plus read exclusive features and interviews that only appear in the print edition, by subscribing online.