The commission had acted after receiving complaints, starting in 2008, from non-British EU nationals living in the UK. They had been refused social security benefits and tax credits “on the grounds that they did not have a right of residence in” Britain, according to the ruling. EU rules allow limitations on social insurance payments to “economically inactive persons”.
The commission charged British authorities with adding residency requirements that were contrary to European freedom of movement rights.
On Tuesday, the European Court of Justice, in Kirchberg, rejected the European Commission’s argument and decided in favour of the UK. “There is nothing to prevent the grant of social benefits to EU citizens who are not economically active being made subject to the requirement that those citizens fulfil the conditions for possessing a right to reside lawfully in the host member state,” the court ruled.
While this may be somewhat discriminatory towards EU expats, “the court considers that this difference in treatment can be justified by a legitimate objective such as the need to protect the finances of the host member state”.
The commission can not appeal the decision.
The case was C-308/14 (Commission v United Kingdom).
Last year the ECJ ruled that the UK could limit unemployment insurance payments to EU nationals.
The timing of this week’s child benefit ruling was considered politically sensitive--as reported by Bloomberg News and EurActiv--as it came just days before Britain’s referendum on potentially exiting the EU.
