Austria’s Supreme Court referred two questions to the European Court of Justice (abbreviated as either the ECJ or CJEU) on Monday as part of a case filed by Max Schrems, an attorney, against the social media firm.
Austrian law allows consumers to “assign” their rights to a lead plaintiff, somewhat similar to a class action suit, according to a press statement issued by Schrems. Facebook argues that consumers lose the right to file claims in their home country with such transfers, meaning Austrian courts do not have jurisdiction to hear the case.
Facebook also says the Schrems is not a consumer, but a commercial activist; Schrems has stresses that he is a private activist.
The ECJ will tell the Vienna court which rulings would be compatible with European law, although Austrian judges will make the final decision in the lawsuit.
These technical questions stem from Schrem’s most recent suit against Facebook Ireland Ltd, which accuses the internet company “of using invalid privacy policies, illegal processing and sharing of personal data or participation in the US mass surveillance scandal,” the plaintiff’s statement read.
In a statement to the Reuters news agency, Facebook said: “Mr. Schrems’s claims have twice been rejected on the grounds that they cannot proceed as ‘class action’ on behalf of other consumers in Austrian courts.”
“We look forward to addressing the procedural questions presented to the CJEU to resolve these claims.”
No hearing dates have been set. Schrems told the TechCrunch news site that: “the average timeframe for the CJEU to issue a ruling is between one and one and a half years.”
Last October, in a case brought by Schrems against the Ireland’s data protection commissioner, the ECJ invalidated the EU-US “Safe Harbour” deal that allowed companies to transfer electronic records across the Atlantic. Brussels and Washington have replacing it with the “Privacy Shield” agreement, which may face a legal challenge by the data protection agency in Hamburg next year.
