Antoine Deltour and Raphaël Halet, both former employees of the consultancy PwC, stand accused of stealing and leaking thousands of confidential tax documents to Édouard Perrin, a journalist charged as an accomplice.
Prosecutors have asked for a sentence of 18 months and financial penalties for Deltour and Halet; and an unspecified fine to be levied against Perrin. The defendants claim they were engaged in legitimate acts of whistleblowing.
On Wednesday, during closing arguments in its civil action, an attorney for PwC blasted the “misleading mixups” presented by the defence. Deltour “became the ambassador for transparency starting at the moment he needed a [legal] defence strategy” and Halet was “an opportunist”.
Addressing the gap between Deltour’s departure from the firm and the time he shared the documents with the press, his lawyer said Deltour wanted to fight against dubious tax practices, but initially did not know how.
Halet’s attorney said the firm pressured him into a signing a confidentiality agreement by threatening to sue him for €10m. PwC denied that allegation.
A prosecutor then argued that Perrin “considered himself above the law” and his actions were not covered by article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which guarantees freedom of expression “and to receive and impart information”. Perrin’s counsel replied: “From the moment you break the Luxembourg criminal code, you no longer have the right to article 10?”
The judges have seven weeks to deliberate.
Reported by Camille Frati; edited by Aaron Grunwald
