The regulator criticises the firm for allowing its safeguard account to remain underfunded for long periods. Flaws in the design of the systems and inadequate controls are said to have prevented Coinbase Ireland from correctly calculating and safeguarding the amounts owed to its customers.  (Photo: Shutterstock)

The regulator criticises the firm for allowing its safeguard account to remain underfunded for long periods. Flaws in the design of the systems and inadequate controls are said to have prevented Coinbase Ireland from correctly calculating and safeguarding the amounts owed to its customers.  (Photo: Shutterstock)

The Central Bank of Ireland has fined Coinbase Ireland €3.25 million, nearly a year after imposing an initial fine of €21.46 million. Both decisions were published following the relocation of the European crypto division to Luxembourg, but relate to breaches committed prior to that move.

Coinbase had promised to make Dublin its European headquarters. It ultimately chose Luxembourg. Since this U-turn, the Irish regulator has imposed two fines on the group totalling 24.72 million euros.

The most recent announcement was made on Thursday 22 October. The Central Bank of Ireland has fined Coinbase Ireland Limited €3.25 million for breaches of the rules governing the protection of client funds and the supervision of outsourced activities. The events took place between 1 November 2020 and 19 August 2025.

Whilst there is no public evidence to suggest that these moves are a response to Coinbase’s partial withdrawal or that the Irish investigations prompted this transfer, the timing nevertheless reveals a strained regulatory relationship.

In October 2023, Coinbase announced that it had chosen Ireland as the location for its future European licence under the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA). At the time, the group praised Ireland’s favourable policy environment for financial technology and the quality of its regulatory framework. Coinbase changed course less than two years later. On 20 June 2025, the company obtained its MiCA authorisation from the Financial Sector Supervisory Commission (CSSF) and announced that it would establish its European crypto hub in Luxembourg. Customer migrations began in August 2025 and continued in waves until October. Users residing in the Grand Duchy switched to Coinbase Luxembourg on 22 September.

Two different entities

The first consequences of the Irish proceedings became apparent following this transfer. On 6 November 2025, the Central Bank of Ireland imposed a fine of €21.46 million on Coinbase Europe Limited, the former company responsible for crypto services. Errors in its system had prevented the proper monitoring of more than 30 million transactions, representing €176 billion. The breaches, which occurred between April 2021 and March 2025, had therefore ceased three months before the Luxembourg licence was granted.

The second decision concerns another company within the group and another part of its business. Coinbase Ireland Limited was not responsible for the custody or trading of crypto-assets, but rather for electronic money services which, amongst other things, enable European customers to hold and use their euros on the platform. The regulator criticises the company for allowing its reserve account to remain insufficiently funded for long periods. Flaws in the design of the systems and inadequate controls are said to have prevented Coinbase Ireland from correctly calculating and safeguarding the amounts owed to its customers. The Irish subsidiary is also said to have relied too heavily on the US group’s services to fulfil its regulatory obligations. According to the Central Bank, it did not have sufficient local expertise to oversee this function. Furthermore, it is alleged that certain significant changes to the fund protection mechanism were not reported to it.

The regulator’s tone is particularly stern. It considers it ‘completely unacceptable’ for a company to fail to honour the commitments made when it was granted authorisation or to fail to inform the regulator of material changes. This criticism is directed at the breaches identified at Coinbase Ireland and not at the choice of Luxembourg.

Coinbase states that it itself reported several issues in January 2024 and has since rectified them. No customers are reported to have lost any money or been prevented from accessing their funds. The company states that it has strengthened its technical controls, reviewed the calculation of the amounts to be protected, appointed a fund safeguard officer and taken out a guarantee of 25 million euros.

A response to the issues at Silvergate Bank

Some of the events date back to the US banking crisis of 2023. When Silvergate Bank found itself facing bankruptcy, Coinbase Ireland asked 30 customers to transfer their dollars to an account held by another company within the group. As a result, their deposits were commingled with funds belonging to another entity, in breach of segregation rules. The company acknowledged the breaches and accepted the findings of the regulator. The fine had initially been set at €4,646,597. The agreement reached with the Central Bank reduced it by 30 per cent, to €3,252,618. It is still subject to confirmation by the Irish High Court.

The decision to move to Luxembourg does not mean that Coinbase has left Ireland. The group retains around 130 employees there, as well as its European payment centre. Crucially, Coinbase Ireland continues to provide e-money services to customers in the European Economic Area. The platform now operates on a distributed architecture spanning both countries. Coinbase Luxembourg handles the custody, purchase, sale and transfer of crypto-assets under the supervision of the CSSF. Coinbase Ireland manages fiat currency wallets and associated payments under the supervision of the Central Bank of Ireland.

When a Luxembourg customer deposits euros before buying bitcoins, the first part of the transaction is therefore handled by the Irish entity and the second by Coinbase Luxembourg. The fine is not directed at the Luxembourg-based company and does not implicate the CSSF. It does, however, concern an entity that remains part of the user journey for Coinbase users in Luxembourg.

The breaches for which penalties were imposed came to an end on 19 August 2025, which was when the first European migrations to the Luxembourg entity began. The Irish decision does not specify whether any clients resident in Luxembourg were affected during the period under review.