Filed by the Luxembourg Court of Cassation in several cases between frontier workers and the Caisse pour l'avenir des enfants (CAE), the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) had to determine whether a frontier worker could claim family allowances for the child of his or her spouse or registered partner, in the absence of a parent-child relationship. Luxembourg law makes this entitlement conditional on the worker providing for the maintenance of the child, a concept which, in administrative practice, had given rise to refusals based on the absence of a direct and individualised financial contribution.
In its judgment, the Court adopts a concrete and social reading of this condition. It considers that the fact of living under the same roof as the child constitutes an objective criterion for presuming that the worker actually provides for the child's maintenance. In the CJEU's view, cohabitation is an expression of real, day-to-day care, which cannot be reduced to an accounting demonstration of the expenses incurred for the child. To require detailed financial proof would be tantamount to imposing stricter conditions on frontier workers than those applicable to resident workers, in contradiction with the principle of equal treatment enshrined in EU law.
The Court points out that family allowances are both social security benefits and social advantages linked to employment. As such, a frontier worker must enjoy the same benefits as a national worker, provided that he is in a comparable situation. The decisive criterion is, therefore, neither the biological link nor the residence of the child in the State of employment, but the reality of family life and the maintenance provided. Community of life thus becomes the pivot of the assessment of the law.
Possibility of refusal
The CJEU specifies, however, that national authorities retain the possibility of refusing to grant benefits in the event of a manifest lack of care or proven fraud. On the other hand, they may not systematically introduce additional requirements aimed at quantifying or individualising the worker's financial contribution where cohabitation has been established.
This ruling puts an end to a legal uncertainty arising from the 2016 Luxembourg reform, which had restricted access to family allowances for the blended families of frontier workers. It is likely to have concrete effects on many cases that are underway or frozen pending the Court's position.
"For a long time, the CAE has endeavoured, as far as frontier workers are concerned, to restrict the circle of beneficiaries of family allowances. Indeed, it considers it excessive that 47.32% of family benefits are exported abroad, despite the presence, in 2024, of 47% of cross-border workers on Luxembourg territory", commented the OGBL on Friday 19 December, assuring that it would closely monitor the development of the legislation in Luxembourg.



