Luxembourg in May dropped out of the top 20 of the Press Freedom Index, landing in 21st place out of 180 countries assessed on the political, economic and sociocultural context of journalism, legal frameworks and the safety of media professionals.
Luxembourg’s worst score was in the legislative framework as the country is still lacking comprehensive freedom of information laws. “Access to state-held information is not guaranteed, despite repeated requests from the journalists’ union,” Reporters Without Borders said.
Under new rules that will come into effect next month, ministries must reply to media requests within 24 hours (or one working day), either including the information sought or--in case this isn’t immediately available--a deadline when it will be supplied. Should a department withhold information for legal reasons, it must cite the laws under which it is being withheld.
The Luxembourg association of professional journalists (ALJP) in May last year had launched a campaign lobbying for ministries and public administrations to be obligated to respond to media requests.
“The right to information for journalists isn’t a privilege, but an indispensable tool and right to fulfil our legal obligation to inform the public and civil society,” a statement said.
The ALJP has frequently criticised that ministries are slow to respond to requests for information or that some enquiries simply go unanswered. During a meeting with the ALJP, prime minister Xavier Bettel (DP)--who is also media minister--had pledged to provide solutions to improve the flow of information.
He also said that a 2018 law, which created a so-called commission on the access to documents (CAD) where the media and other public and private stakeholders can request access to information from the government and communes, would be overhauled.
A long list of documents is excluded from the commission’s reach and its opinions are consultative, meaning the government can choose to withhold the information even after the commission has said it should be released.



