The government wants to put an end to a terminology deemed stigmatising and scientifically outdated for obesity, favouring a global approach that takes into account metabolic, psychological and social factors, which is welcomed by the Collège Médical. Photo: Shutterstock

The government wants to put an end to a terminology deemed stigmatising and scientifically outdated for obesity, favouring a global approach that takes into account metabolic, psychological and social factors, which is welcomed by the Collège Médical. Photo: Shutterstock

The government’s bill to adapt the 2018 Hospital Act is attracting both approval and criticism from the Collège Médical, according to its opinion issued this morning. The institution recognises progress, particularly in the fight against obesity and clarification of the role of health reserve beds, but warns of unclear areas and risks associated with the future organisation of care.

Bill no. 8575, currently under discussion, aims to thoroughly overhaul hospital planning in Luxembourg by 2040. Among its key measures, the bill provides for the gradual integration of 200 health reserve beds into the four acute care hospitals (CHL, CHEM, CHdN and HRS). This capacity, created during the covid-19 pandemic, could now be mobilised not only in the event of a crisis, but also to meet changing public health needs. The government stresses that it wants to prevent these beds from remaining inactive, while retaining the possibility of requisitioning them in the event of a national emergency.

The Collège Médical welcomes this clarification, which it sees as a flexible tool for adapting the healthcare system. However, it insists on the need to ensure that these beds do not become a permanent adjustment variable to the detriment of transparent and predictable planning. In its view, they must be integrated into hospital capacity without blurring the distinction between structural needs and crisis management, in order to avoid chronic overloading of establishments.

Another major change is that the draft replaces the term “morbid obesity” with “obesity with co-morbidity.” The government justifies this choice by the desire to put an end to a terminology deemed stigmatising and scientifically outdated, by favouring a global approach that takes into account metabolic, psychological and social factors. The Collège Médical is in favour of this change, which is in line with the recommendations of the Healthcare Scientific Council and the Standing Committee on Hospitals.

On the other hand, the institution has reservations about certain adjustments concerning the number of beds per speciality, particularly in palliative care and rehabilitation. In its view, the demographic and medical projections put forward by the government, while useful, remain fragile in the face of uncertainty about changes in medical practices and the ageing of the population. It advocates more regular updating of the assessments and greater consultation with practitioners in the field.

While the Collège Médical recognises the effort made to plan ahead and align with international scientific standards, it warns against the risk of rigidity or imprecision in application. Its opinion illustrates the delicate balance that the legislator will have to strike between operational flexibility and securing hospital resources.

This article was originally published in French.