According to the minister for health and social security, Martine Deprez (CSV), the authorisation of the Caisse médico-complémentaire mutualiste is in order and there is currently no reason to suspend or withdraw it, according to the minutes of a debate in the Chamber of Deputies in March initiated by the Greens.
However, on 9 August, the administrative courts annulled the approval of the Caisse médico-complémentaire mutualiste (CMCM). “Under the 2019 law, a mutual insurance company must provide benefits that must remain variable depending on the resources available,” says the ruling. “However, neither the CMCM’s articles of association nor any other element in the file establish that this legal condition is met. The court therefore concludes that the ministry could not validly conclude that the above condition had been met by CMCM and could therefore not validly approve CMCM. It is also important to note that, in the absence of any mechanism for informing members of this essential legal condition for classification as a mutual, it is unlikely that members will be informed that CMCM’s benefits must remain variable, unlike approved insurers, which must respect their contractual commitments at all times.”
Unfair competition, according to Aca Santé
For several years, says Aca Santé in a position paper signed by its president Marc Hengen, Aca Santé and its members have believed that CMCM’s activities do not comply with the law, “illegally carrying on insurance activities governed by the law of 7 December 2015.”
“The exercise of insurance activities, as defined by the said law, is subject to numerous obligations that CMCM does not fulfil. This situation has created, according to Aca Santé and its members, unfair competition between CMCM and duly authorised insurance companies, and prejudice for the latter.”
“This decision has far-reaching consequences for CMCM, since it is tantamount to considering that it is carrying out its activities without authorisation,” comments Aca Santé.
Despite the crisis of governance, CMCM continues to gain 2% to 3% more customers each year. It currently has 280,000 customers, a market that is whetting the appetites of commercial insurers. The mutual insurer considers that it is not subject to the same solvency and supervision rules as classic insurance companies. These companies argue that the CMCM has ventured into ‘their’ territory by offering group contracts. The CMCM, on the other hand, believes that they have the right to do so.
The health ministry has 40 days in which to lodge an appeal. Contacted by Paperjam, the ministry stated: “The services in charge of the case within the ministry of health and social security are currently analysing the judgment in order to explore and understand its scope and the avenues to pursue.”
Paperjam also contacted CMCM for comment, who said in response: “As an interested party in the proceedings, the CMCM is closely following the analyses of the ministry of health and social security. It is not taking a position on this subject and continues to honour its commitments, support and help its members as best it can in their medical journey.”
This article was originally published in French.
Updated on 20 August at 14:25 with a comment from CMCM.



